Written by
Date published
"Shifting eating to the circadian rest phase misaligns the peripheral clocks with the master SCN clock and leads to a metabolic syndrome"
McHill AW et al., 2017 | Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)
Study Summary
This study explored how sleep deprivation combined with nighttime eating affects metabolic health in humans. Participants underwent a controlled forced desynchrony protocol, where their eating and sleep schedules were shifted to occur at biologically “wrong” times (during internal night). The goal was to isolate the effects of circadian misalignment from mere sleep loss
Experimental Design
- Participants: Healthy adults (n ≈ 8–16 depending on specific group)
- Protocol:
- Used a 20-hour forced desynchrony (FD) cycle to separate sleep/wake and circadian rhythms
- Randomized into control (normal sleep-wake/eating) vs. chronic sleep restriction (CSR) or
- Diet: Isocaloric meals distributed evenly across wake periods
- Measurements:
- Fasting glucose, insulin, leptin, ghrelin, adiponectin, cortisol
- Subjective hunger ratings
- Hormone and metabolic profiles across circadian phases
night-eating conditions
Key Findings
- Circadian Rhythms Dominate
- Hunger and hormones (leptin, ghrelin, insulin, glucose, adiponectin, cortisol) followed strong circadian patterns regardless of sleep restriction PubMed+4Frontiers+4PNAS+4.
- No Major Shift with Sleep Restriction Alone
- Chronic sleep restriction (CSR) did not significantly alter fasting hormone levels or subjective hunger rhythms PubMed+11Frontiers+11PubMed+11.
- Misaligned Eating Matters More
- Eating during the biological night (rest phase) led to peripheral clock misalignment, contributing to metabolic disturbances like insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome risk PNAS+2PNAS+2Frontiers+2.
- Hormonal Effects of Night Eating
- Nighttime eating produced higher post-meal glucose and insulin levels compared to daytime feeding, despite the same calorie intake.
Why It Matters
- Clarifies drivers: It’s not sleep loss alone—but eating at the wrong circadian time that triggers metabolic dysfunction.
- Supports chrono-nutrition: Bolsters the idea that aligning meal timing with our internal clock helps maintain metabolic health.
- Implications for shift workers: Those eating during biological night might be at greater risk—even if caloric intake and sleep duration remain stable.
Practical Takeaway
- Avoid eating late at night or during periods aligned with your body's internal rest phase.
- Even if you work night shifts or sleep less, try to align your main meals with your internal wake phase.
- Chrono-aligned eating may offer protective metabolic benefits, potentially reducing the risk of insulin resistance and other circadian-related disorders.